Rule Vote : Banning HB Direct Snap

[djKianoosh]

I know there is a good enough amount of people who want to do away with this play, but we need specifics. Do we want to ban ALL HB Direct snap type plays, or is there a specific one that is being abused?

Also, do we want to ban it outright or limit it to a certain number of plays per game? per quarter? etc etc.. .

I'll convert this thread into a poll once we get some options out there.

discussion of the glitch itself: http://www.maddentips.com/forums/showthread.php?t=128814

[Iamonebigmofo]

I know there is a good enough amount of people who want to do away with this play, but we need specifics. Do we want to ban ALL HB Direct snap type plays, or is there a specific one that is being abused?

Also, do we want to ban it outright or limit it to a certain number of plays per game? per quarter? etc etc.. .

I'll convert this thread into a poll once we get some options out there.

Personally, I don't think we should ban all HB direct plays because in other formations it's not as much of an issue. The Doubles On one in NE's pb is because of the multiple screen plays in the same set. It doesn't really matter much to me either way though.

[MoneyMo]

Personally, I don't think we should ban all HB direct plays because in other formations it's not as much of an issue. The Doubles On one in NE's pb is because of the multiple screen plays in the same set. It doesn't really matter much to me either way though.


I personally think we should ban all HB direct plays. It makes it easier to monitor and less room for questioning the rules.

[huntin1]

I personally think we should ban all HB direct plays. It makes it easier to monitor and less room for questioning the rules.

I agree. If we ban 1 we need to ban them all.

[Indecline]

http://pugsly.bechange.com/forum_fodder/ban_them_all.jpg

[jerseyjay14]

ban it or allow it... no "limiting"

[djKianoosh]

Please vote on banning this play now. Thanks.

[Highlander]

I voted allow it but if its banned NP.

[Comeback QB]

whats wrong with this play? I was using it ... was like wow a run play that works in shotgun.

[djKianoosh]

this was the discussion that talked about it: http://www.maddentips.com/forums/showthread.php?t=128814

if moneymo and huntin are saying it's a pain and not very fun, I will have to agree with them on the matter.

[djKianoosh]

About half the league has voted so far. I'll let this go until thursday night then we'll close the poll.

[GiantNFC7]

I vote to ban it, I find people tend to use it as a crutch once their gameplan begins to get shut down (not talking about people in this league, but in general its human nature to look for a quick fix)

[Comeback QB]

Seeing as you can record 10 plays a game, maybe a ban is too drastic.

How about a limit to using it. No more than 2 times a game kinda thing.

Btw i looked at this and this is not the play I use ever ... so its not like if I get in I would use it.

[miracle]

ban it or allow it... no "limiting"


agreed... im for either.. but no limiting