Peyton Manning OVR 93 want to rethink that now?

[Nevada_Ballin]

Interesting....... you do understand I'm not talking about Peyton of 3 years ago right? I'm talking about right now today. So I can qoute you saying that Peyton is going to have a better year than every one of those QBs is that right?

I understand exactly what you are saying and I'm saying you are wrong

Define "better year". If it's solely off statistics then that's too narrow.


.

[Golf_Pro]

You realize statistics are not the defining criteria for greatness, right?


.

Why is this so hard to understand? I am not saying Peyton isn't top ten ALL TIME! I am simply saying he is not in the TOP 10 GOING INTO THIS YEAR!

AHAHAH I GIVE UP I GAVE IT MY BEST! I tried to make a valid argument but I GUESS PEYTON WILL WIN THE MVP THIS YEAR GO BRONCOS!

[Nevada_Ballin]

Why is this so hard to understand? I am not saying Peyton isn't top ten ALL TIME! I am simply saying he is not in the TOP 10 THIS YEAR!

AHAHAH I GIVE UP I GAVE IT MY BEST! I GUESS PEYTON WILL WIN THE MVP THIS YEAR GO BRONCOS!

I didn't say anything about all time anywhere... but you keep saying you are basing this off "statistics" from last year. I'm not giving statistics any credibility here. Make up your mind, what are you basing your assessment on? Stats from last year or a pre-season game from a couple of days ago?


.

[Golf_Pro]

I didn't say anything about all time anywhere... but you keep saying you are basing this off "statistics" from last year. I'm not giving statistics any credibility here. Make up your mind, what are you basing your assessment on? Stats from last year or a pre-season game from a couple of days ago?


.

Its all good if you go back and actually read what I posted it will make sense. Im over it! Are you on ps3 we should play this year?

[Nevada_Ballin]

Its all good if you go back and actually read what I posted it will make sense. Im over it! Are you on ps3 we should play this year?

lol yes we will agree to disagree. Yep I'm on PS3.... since you have that user name, do you play Tiger Woods also? If so we need to get on with some of that too

PSN Name = nevadaballin


.

[mannmicj]

HOLY CRAP I'm not talking about Peyton in his prime I'm talking about THIS season!

I am still laughing. Guess what, "IT'S STILL THE PRESEASON"

[mannmicj]

Did you read anything I posted? What are you talking about years left in the league??? I said in about 5 different post that my opinion is based off of last years stats for my top ten not years left in the league. Manning is coming over nearly a career ending injury and hasn't played football in two years. My main point was that rating should be based on stats and play from year to year.

I am laughing even more now. Ratings and attributes should be based on more than just one season. Consistency matters, unless you want more Peyton Hillis type ratings, see Madden 12 original ratings.

Injuries happen. His THP and INJ attribute suffered for that injury. I will wait until the regular season is well underway before I write off Manning as a top 5 QB. If anyone has earned the benefit of the doubt, it's Manning. Remember, before 2011, he played 13 consecutive seasons (plus Playoffs) without missing a start.

[GREENERRRR]

Clearly he gets a 1 year pass based on past performace.... I dont have a problem wityh his rating - besides when the games are for real - u will see different results.,..

[bahdbwoy]

Want to rethink this thread now?

Pencil them in as AFC West winners for atleast next 3 years--- you can use a sharpie instead of pencil actually.

[Gaberox]

Can we get an increase for Thomas as well. He is a top WR at this point. Manning is still Manning he should get a good boost to his medium throw accuracy after this game.